The standard behind the work
What may be claimed depends on what can be proved.
A report should never be judged on appearance alone. The X Standard defines what evidence must exist before we make a claim about its quality, integrity or ability to support a decision.
The dimensions
What a report is read against.
Seven things, named without weights, thresholds or a formula: those are still being calibrated, so they are not published here.
- 01
Audience and mandate
Who the report is actually for, and what it was commissioned to do.
- 02
The decision
The specific decision the report exists to support, and the person accountable for it.
- 03
The first five seconds
What a first-time reader sees before they read anything — the leading question, or the absence of one.
- 04
The truth of what is shown
Whether the numbers on screen match what the underlying model and source actually support.
- 05
The path through it
Whether the report leads somewhere a person can act, or stops at the numbers.
- 06
The craft
The ordinary discipline of a well-built report — clarity, consistency, restraint.
- 07
Accessibility
A floor that gates a result rather than a dimension that trades against the others — it never moves the band, it can only stop one.
The evidence ladder
Evidence decides what may be said.
Six kinds of evidence, ranked. The order is the point: each rung allows a stronger claim than the one below it.
- 00
Screenshot only
What the report looks like, with nothing behind it confirmed.
- 01
+ the answers of the person who owns the decision
The decision, the audience and the mandate, taken directly from the accountable person.
- 02
+ the report's own definition files
The measures and their written definitions, as the report itself declares them.
- 03
+ the semantic model
The relationships, grain and keys underneath the definitions, not just the definitions in isolation.
- 04
+ how it behaves when run
The report exercised across real states and filters, not just inspected at rest.
- 05
+ evidence of how it is actually used
Observed use by the people it was built for, not a claim about how it is intended to be used.
The principle
A result can never claim more than the evidence that produced it.
The gates
What stops a result
- 01
No decision contract means no score at all
Without an accountable decision on file, nothing is issued — not a low score, no score.
- 02
A critical finding suppresses the composite
While a critical finding is open, the composite is withheld, not shown with a caveat.
- 03
An unassessed dimension is left unassessed
A dimension without enough evidence is marked as such, never interpolated from the others.
- 04
A result never outruns its tier
The evidence tier behind a result caps what the result is allowed to claim, regardless of how the numbers would otherwise read.
How a result reads
A band, with its tier and its coverage.
Where the evidence carries one, a result is stated as a band, with the evidence tier behind it and how much of the report that tier covered. Never a single number that invites false precision.
76–84
at Tier 2 (indicative), coverage 0.71
Never “83/100”. A band always travels with its tier and its coverage, and while a critical finding is open there is no band at all.
The boundary
What a result does not certify.
The boundary
A result does not certify correctness, and it does not certify accessibility conformance.
It says nothing about states that were not examined. The standard is used to decide what may be said about a report; it is not sold as a certification, and none is issued.
Where it is applied
The standard runs through every stage.
Each stage of the method is held to it: what a review may conclude, what a redesign must carry, what a build hands over, and what verification may claim.
Current status
Calibration in progress · no certification issuedThe X Standard is being calibrated against real reports. Thresholds remain under validation. No certification is issued today.
Status as at 2026-09-26
Next
See the standard applied.
The standard only means something against a real report. Bring one.