04 / xVerify
Proof that what changed was meant to change.
Prove, for the states examined, that the intended meaning survived the change. xVerify compares the report before and after the work and states exactly what changed, what did not, and what the comparison cannot tell you.
The comparison
What is compared.
Three things, always in this order.
- 01
Structure
What the report is made of — the model, the measures, the visuals — before and after the work.
- 02
Behaviour
The same questions asked of both versions, across the states the audience actually uses, with every difference reported rather than sampled.
- 03
Closure
Every finding from the review is re-tested against the new artefact, not just noted as addressed.
The proof
What it has to prove
- 01
Every observed difference maps to a declared change
Nothing shifts in the numbers without a named reason on file for it.
- 02
Every finding that was false is now true
A resolved finding is checked again, not assumed resolved because the redesign said so.
- 03
No measure kept its name and changed its meaning
If a definition moved, the name has to say so — a silent rename is treated as a failure, not a detail.
The refusal
What it refuses to conclude.
The refusal
Within the states examined, xVerify checks that observed differences map to declared changes. It does not prove global correctness or the absence of change in states that were not tested.
It does not claim the redesign is better than what it replaced. It says nothing about states it did not test. And a number that was wrong in both versions verifies clean — verification is not the same claim as correctness.
How it is done
Tie-outs, by hand, on the record.
Limits
Verification is part of the engagement, not a product.
Each engagement is verified with explicit tie-outs against the source and against the previous version, recorded with the handover. There is no standalone verification software on offer, and a verification is never presented as a certificate.
Next
Start where the evidence starts.
Nothing is compared until something has been reviewed first.